Home // ICDS 2011, The Fifth International Conference on Digital Society // View article

A Performance Analysis of Snort and Suricata Network Intrusion Detection and Prevention Engines

Authors:
David Day
Benjamin Burns

Keywords: snort; suricata; performance; NIDS; NIDPS;

Abstract:
Recently, there has been shift to multi-core processors and consequently multithreaded application design. Multithreaded Network Intrusion Detection and Prevention Systems (NIDPS) are now being considered. Suricata is a multithreaded open source NIDPS, being developed via the Open Information Security Forum(OISF). It is increasing in popularity, as it free to use under the General Public Licence (GPL), with open source code. This paper describes an experiment, comprising of a series of innovative tests to establish whether Suricata shows an increase in accuracy and system performance over the de facto standard, single threaded NIDPS Snort. Results indicate that Snort has a lower system overhead than Suricata and this translates to fewer false negatives utilising a single core, stressed environment. However, Suricata is shown to be more accurate in environments where multi-cores are available. Suricata is shown to be scalable through increased performance when running on four cores; however, even when running on four cores its ability to process a 2Mb pcap file is still less than Snort. In this regard, there is no benefit to utilising multi-cores whenrunning a single instance of Snort.

Pages: 187 to 192

Copyright: Copyright (c) IARIA, 2011

Publication date: February 23, 2011

Published in: conference

ISSN: 2308-3956

ISBN: 978-1-61208-116-8

Location: Gosier, Guadeloupe, France

Dates: from February 23, 2011 to February 28, 2011