Materials: [ Cód.: MotorSimSimple.mlx ] [ PDF ]
This video analyzes the frequency response and time-domain behavior of three different models of a DC motor driving a mechanical load.
It compares the frequency response of a ‘full’ second-order motor model with a simplified first-order model where the electrical dynamics are neglected (inductance set to zero). The comparison is first made by simply superimposing the Bode plots, and then by plotting the magnitude Bode plot of the ’relative error’, defined as between a given and .
A ’quasi-static’ model is also compared, where all dynamics are neglected, i.e., simplifying the equations to just the static gain. This model is suitable for simply describing the motor’s behavior with very low bandwidth signals: low frequency sinusoid or very slow transitions between operating points.
Building upon the frequency domain analysis, this video then uses time-domain simulations to gain a better practical understanding of interpreting Bode plots, especially for non-sinusoidal but ’smooth’ signals connecting two constant operating points. An informal notion of signal ’bandwidth’ is discussed, relating it to the signal’s rise time and the duration it stays at a level, connecting this to the equivalent frequency in a sinusoidal signal.
Time simulations are proposed here to better understand the interpretation. There are two types of simulations:
Sinusoidal input: This is what (apart from an initial transient) the Bode plot is expected to predict.
Smooth transition between operating points: This involves interpolating between two speed levels using a sinusoidal half-period; the signal remains at such levels for a time before changing to another operating point. This is closer to certain practical situations and approaches the theoretical concept of a ’band-limited signal’, which generalizes Bode plot ideas to non-sinusoidal signals (whose Fourier transform has very small components above a certain frequency). Limiting the signal’s frequency content is important to avoid exciting vibrations or other unmodeled high-frequency phenomena.
The video thus covers the comparison of different motor model orders (0th, 1st, and 2nd) in the frequency domain and uses time simulations to provide a practical interpretation of frequency response, particularly for signals encountered in real-world control application scenarios.
*Link to my [ whole collection] of videos in English. Link to larger [ Colección completa] in Spanish.