Materials: [ Cód.: MotorSimSimple.mlx ] [ PDF ]
In this video, we discuss the time response (step response) comparison
between a 2nd-order DC motor driving a mechanical load and a 1st-order
approximation neglecting the inductance dynamics in the electrical subsystem
().
Details on modelling and order reduction were discussed in videos [
In here, we show that when inertia is ‘large’ then accelerating the load takes a lot of time compared to the electrical time constant and the simplified model is valid. If inertia is made 10 times lower, then the 1st-order approximation behaves badly because the actual 2nd-order systems exhibits oscillations in the transient, which cannot be modelled by a 1st-order system, of course.
Of course step response comparison is meaningful only in applications where motor will be ‘on’ at a constant value for a long time. In fast maneuvres, comparison in frequency domain might be a better option. The idea is discussed in other videos in the collection.
*Link to my [ whole collection] of videos in English. Link to larger [ Colección completa] in Spanish.